The War of the Sexes: Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

 In Leadership, Leadership Development, management, Rick Conlow
Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?Are women better than men in leadership roles? It has been 168 years since the United States got its first woman doctor, Elizabeth Blackwell. Twenty-nine colleges turned down her applications for medical school. She was ridiculed and told it “wasn’t women’s work”. But she didn’t quit. Finally, Hobart College accepted her. almost on a whim. The faculty and Dean really didn’t know how to respond to her. So, thinking she had no chance, they said they would admit her if 100% of the 150 male students voted yes. They voted unanimously to accept her.Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

After completing her degree, Elizabeth continued her studies in Europe. Just like in America, discrimination rose strongly against her. She was allowed to be enrolled in La Maternité clinic/hospital as a student midwife, but not accredited as a physician. She did gain much additional medical experience. Eventually returning to America, she starting writing and lecturing to make her way. She created the Blackwell Sisters that helped in the Civil War. Blackwell steadfastly dealt with all obstacles and went on to establish hospitals in New York and London. While engaged in medicine she championed many social reforms in the US and Europe.

Inequalities for Women in Today’s Workplace in the US

Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

Women in America still face great inequalities in the workplace, as identified in a recent Chicago Tribune article. For example:

  • Women are rated lower in their competence by U.S. decision makers (mostly white males).
  • Pay is one third less than males in the same job, over a lifetime.
  • Lack of recognition or credit.
  • Men are promoted more on potential, women on performance.
  • Few second chances.

Worldwide discrimination and inferior treatment haunt women of all nationalities. Opportunities are much fewer compared to men. Incredibly, in 2017, men in most nationalities still believe that they are superior to women.

Women Leaders vs. Men Leaders

Most of the women leaders that I have engaged through LinkedIn or consulting projects continually exhibit the qualities that Elizabeth Blackwell demonstrated by breaking the glass ceiling in medicine so many years ago. Businesses, this country, and the world desperately need better leaders. In their highly disengaged state, employees are begging for transformational leaders. Research suggests compelling evidence that many women tend to adopt more effective leadership approaches and styles than men. According to personality profiler Dr. Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic, men have a tendency to narcissism and hubris which often leads to serious leadership mistakes and failure. Studies show that men tend to obtain more leadership roles because confidence is confused for competence.

The Next Revolution in Leadership Thought

Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

Elizabeth Blackwell confronted discrimination in a time that was even more male-dominated. She forged ahead and said, “My mind is fully made up. I have not the slightest hesitation on the subject; the thorough study of medicine, I am quite resolved to go through with. The horrors and disgusts I have no doubt of vanquishing. I have overcome stronger distastes than any that now remain, and feel fully equal to the contest. As to the opinion of people, I don’t care one straw personally; though I take so many pains, as a matter of policy, to propitiate it, and shall always strive to do so; for I see continually how the highest good is eclipsed by the violent or disagreeable forms which contain it.”

I believe all people have tremendous potential. It doesn’t matter where you are from or if you are male or female. With discrimination in the workplace women, women leaders become better than men simply because they work at it more. They become “students of the game.” I believe that the next great advance in leadership thought will be the power of people. I also believe that women could finally be at the forefront of this movement. What do you think?

For accelerated individual online leadership training go here: RCI Online Leadership Training.

Want to accelerate your career? Check out one my books in the Superstar Book Series for a boost.

Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

 

Are Women Leaders Better than Men Leaders?

Rick Conlow
Rick Conlow is the CEO & Founder of Rick Conlow International, a consulting, training and coaching firm. He has helped over 200 companies such as Target, Costco, Andersen Windows, Spectrum, Northern Power, Meijer, Carpet King, International Truck, John Deere, Lowes Financial, and Canadian Linen improve customer loyalty, increase sales and add profits. Rick has been a general manager, vice president, training director, program director, and national sales trainer. He has authored 22 books, and regularly speaks at conferences and to audiences of all sizes.
Recommended Posts

Leave a Comment

Contact Us

Have a question? Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text.