HUMAN RESOURCES: WHO TOOK THE HUMAN OUT OF IT?
Who took the “human” out of human resources? The pendulum has swung and is stuck, in favor of companies managing employees as human capital. In other words, nameless commodities. HR teams support this while trying to garner executive approval. I believe it has caused them to lose their way. It is wreaking havoc with employee trust and engagement. As a result, disengagement is 77% globally.
- Gallup declares employee engagement achieved a ten-year low.
- HBR identifies that trust continues to decline in the workplace.
- Accenture shares leaders shift away from people-first solutions to performance.
A Google search of the question, “What is the purpose of the Human Resource Department?” yielded the following laudable response at the top of the page.
“The mission of Human Resources is to maintain a fair, equitable, and positive work environment for all employees, in support of the mission of the organization. It is based upon the belief that the success of any organization, and its ultimate value, is primarily dependent upon its people. Furthermore, that the development of the greatest potential for each employee will create job satisfaction. In addition, this maximizes the career opportunities for individuals and provides maximum benefit to the organization.”
ADVERSARIES, NOT ADVOCATES
The statement is a little wordy, but I like the above statement. To me, Human Resource’s purpose involves the important task of providing protection, development, and opportunity for all employees while supporting an organization’s profitable success. That is not the case today. A poll by CareerBliss.com showed 72% of employees see HR has a management pawn. Plus, only 7% say it looks out for employees. HR seems highly focused in three areas, quite different from what they must do.
Recently, while discussing 7 Types of Bad Bosses, I stated that an option in dealing with a bad boss is to consult with the HR team. The show’s host immediately showed a look of disbelief. Later she confided in me that there is no way that she would trust their HR group to listen without reprisal. A LinkedIn post I wrote, 6 Proven Ways to Deal with a Bad Boss, included a step to contact HR. That generated comments like this-“contacting HR is a quick way to derail your career.” Countless radio interviews since reveal similar negative comments.
During consulting engagements, our staff hear repeatedly from managers and employees alike that HR is the last place they will go for assistance. Mocked, maligned, and disparaged profanely, the reputation of HR teams is at all-time low. In contrast, I met and know talented HR professionals and they want to do an excellent job. Unfortunately, they have their hands tied by bottom-line focused executives.
HUMAN RESOURCE COMPLIANCE NOT COLLABORATION
Government size proliferates to enact legislates related to tons of labor regulations. (Fair Labor Standards, Equal Employment Opportunity, Occupational Safety and Medical Leave, and others) In all these areas HR must execute appropriately. Likewise, add in a lawsuit-happy world, and too many HR departments focus on documentation, and limiting litigation. Unfortunately, this means damage control to their organization’s reputation not talent development. However, this has led HR to become the “organizational cops” or henchmen that hinder productivity and creativity.
For example, in a $1 billion dollar company I consulted with, field managers resist working with HR because policy non-compliance is severely punishable. Their HR teams are like bureaucratic IRS auditors. The message, manage the same way or risk reprimands, budget cuts, and lack of executive favor.
HUMAN RESOURCES: PROGRAMS NOT PERFORMANCE
An HR leader gave guidance to an experienced and talented manager on how to conduct a performance review on an employee doing poorly. The manager delivered the needed constructive criticism. Yet, the employee filed a formal complaint. Because of that, the manager’s boss fired her. If you must perform a risky role HR does not have your back, for what can you count on them?
Too many managers in my clients’ businesses do not know who in HR supports them. New managers complain about achieving promotions with no training, guidance, or support to execute HR programs and policies. Yet, they manage a large geographically dispersed team. The jobs confront dangerous and technically challenging situations. As an emerging trend involves digitizing all HR functions. Consequently, HR, as with my clients, delegates the implementation and follow-through. HR manages the reports.
HR lacks a bottom-line. One study found HR groups only spend 15% of their time on strategic issues. Too many HR leaders focus on the number of online training sessions, compliance to policies, and EX scores. Only a handful prioritize alignment with executives on business revenue, growth, or profits. So, executives do not take them seriously. HR sits the throne of a back-driver position.
WHAT IS THE COST TO HUMAN RESOURCES?
- Unwillingness to trust. This means, of course, that employees will always save their best for themselves. Without their engagement and commitment, companies get only what employees will give them to get by.
- Lack of openness. When Human Resources ignores or punishes managers for bringing up issues, they learn not to “trouble you” with it. Employees and managers alike learn to tell their leaders only what they want to hear because they receive the “hammer” for telling the truth.
- No ownership. As a result, employees and managers will lack commitment, hard work, and persistence, which is essential for today’s competitive marketplace. In conclusion, productivity, sales, customer service, and profits suffer.
Pulling It All Together
None of us wants to feel alone and at the mercy of arbitrary, incompetent, and sometimes cruel workplace behavior or management practices. Harassment, discrimination, bullying, psychological intimidation, emotional terrorism, office violence – these are just a small list of challenges in business.
I believe that Human Resources must be repurposed to achieve effectiveness and value. Why not focus on partnering with and inspiring the greatest untapped potential of any organization–people? HR must advocate for people-employee engagement and customer engagement. This means HR teams become collaborative coaches that you can count on. Company leaders need the help. Just review the evidence of low employee engagement scores, disappearing customer service, lagging employee retention and the lack of trust in senior leadership. Our workplaces need more humanity and empathy. Servant Leadership approaches provide that and more. This is especially evident with organizations’ frenzied focus on AI. Only when employees feel safe, appreciated, and valued will they bring their absolute best to work.
Personal Career Growth and Servant Leadership Development Resources
Also, do you want to enhance your career by increasing Human Sigma: the EX and CX of your company-today? Download this complimentary eBook guide: The Customer has the Power.
In addition, learn tools to achieve your goals here: GoalPower: How to Increase your Personal Performance and Career Success.
Furthermore, the world desperately needs leaders that have empathy and care. And elevate them as partners. Join the revolution in leadership thought and practice that elevates people first through Servant Leadership on LinkedIn: ServantLeadership@RickConlowInternational
Finally, add to or develop your skills as a Servant Leader by elevating human resources (people) first: 21 Servant Leadership Training Lessons. In addition, go here to accelerate your leadership success and
learn more about Servant Leadership, see Rick’s newest book, The Dynamics of Servant Leadership: Inspire Your Team to Achieve Extraordinary Goals! And, do you want to accelerate your management career? Check
out Rick’s best-selling book, Superstar Leadership Model.









You’re helping the world improved with your work! ??
Hi Robert:
Thanks so much. See this, too.https://rickconlow.com/servant-leaders-walk-the-talk-more-than-talk-the-talk/
The best of success to you. Let me know how I can be of service.
Positively,
Rick